The short answer
Ammonia Analyzers
Ammonia is measured online for three purposes: to control aeration in a treatment plant so that nitrification is complete without wasting blower energy, to control chloramination in a water plant so that free ammonia stays in the narrow band that forms monochloramine without breakpoint or excess, and to monitor effluent for permit compliance. Three technologies serve them: ion-selective electrode probes that sit in the process and read ammonium with compensation for pH, temperature, and potassium; gas-sensing electrodes that raise the sample pH and read ammonia gas through a membrane; and wet-chemistry analyzers that add reagents to a filtered sample and read a color, which are the most accurate and the most demanding. The choice is between the low cost and fast response of a probe and the accuracy of an analyzer, and the maintenance program, cleaning, calibration against laboratory results, and reagent and membrane replacement, is what makes any of them trustworthy for control.
Key points
- Three technologies: ion-selective probes in the process, gas-sensing electrodes with pH elevation, and reagent-based colorimetric analyzers.
- Probes are fast and cheap and drift; analyzers are accurate and slow and need reagents and sample conditioning.
- Ammonium probes need pH, temperature, and potassium compensation; the potassium interference is the one that surprises people.
- The control uses are aeration control, chloramination control, and effluent monitoring, each with its own range and response need.
- Calibration is against laboratory results on grab samples, on a schedule, with the record kept.
Technologies
| Technology | How it works | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ion-selective electrode probe | A membrane electrode responds to ammonium ion in the process; pH and temperature electrodes in the same body compensate; a potassium electrode corrects for the main interference | Immersed in the process, no sample system, fast, low cost | Drift, fouling, potassium and pH sensitivity, electrode life of months, needs matrix calibration |
| Gas-sensing electrode | A reagent raises the sample pH so that ammonium becomes ammonia gas, which diffuses through a membrane to a pH sensor | Fewer ionic interferences, good at low range | Needs a sample system and reagent, membrane and reagent maintenance |
| Colorimetric wet chemistry | A filtered sample is mixed with reagents to form a colored compound that is read photometrically; the salicylate method is common | Accurate, traceable to the laboratory method, stable | Sample filtration and conditioning, reagents, waste, slow cycle, higher cost |
| Ultraviolet or spectral | Some spectral analyzers infer ammonia from the spectrum with a model | No reagents | Matrix dependent; verify against the laboratory |
Uses and ranges
| Application | Typical range | What it controls | Response need |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aeration control | 0 to 10 or 0 to 20 mg/L as nitrogen in the aeration basin | Dissolved oxygen setpoint or blower output to finish nitrification without excess air | Minutes |
| Chloramination | 0 to 1 or 0 to 2 mg/L free ammonia after the chlorine | Ammonia feed to hold a chlorine to ammonia ratio | Minutes; the band is narrow |
| Effluent monitoring | 0 to 5 mg/L | Alarm and record; sometimes a final aeration trim | Tens of minutes acceptable |
| Influent or sidestream | 0 to 50 mg/L or higher | Load estimation, sidestream treatment control | Slow |
Ammonium probes
The probe reads the ammonium ion, and the fraction of total ammonia that is ammonium depends on pH and temperature, so the probe reads pH and temperature and converts. Potassium ions produce a response on the ammonium membrane, and in wastewater the potassium concentration is comparable to the ammonium at the low end of the range, so a potassium electrode is included and its reading subtracted. Membranes age, foul with biofilm and grease, and respond more slowly with time; a probe with an automatic air-blast or wiper cleaning stays useful longer. Calibration is a matrix adjustment against a laboratory result on a grab sample taken beside the probe, at least weekly at first and then as the drift record allows, and the probe is replaced when the slope falls out of range. A probe in the aeration basin sees the process the controller needs to see; a probe on a sample line sees a delayed and altered sample.
Wet-chemistry analyzers
The analyzer draws a sample, filters it through a membrane or a ceramic filter, meters it with reagents, waits for the color to develop, and reads it. The cycle takes a few minutes, and the result matches the laboratory closely because it is the laboratory method automated. What it needs is a sample system that delivers a representative, filtered sample continuously without plugging, reagents replaced on schedule and kept in date, a waste route, a temperature-controlled enclosure, and a technician who cleans the filter and the sample lines before they fail. Where the measurement must be accurate, for a permit or for chloramination control, the analyzer earns its cost; where a trend is enough, a probe does.
Control loops
- Ammonia-based aeration control
- The ammonia at the end of the aeration basin sets the dissolved oxygen setpoint, or the blower output directly, so that the plant supplies only the air nitrification needs. Savings of a fifth to a third of blower energy are typical; the loop is slow, cascaded, and tuned with the dissolved oxygen loop.
- Chloramination
- Free ammonia after chlorine addition is held in a narrow band by trimming the ammonia feed; too little and chlorine breaks through, too much and nitrification starts in the distribution system. The analyzer response and the sample lag set how tight the control can be.
- Effluent alarm
- A rising effluent ammonia is a nitrification upset hours in the making; the alarm and the trend give the operator time to act on aeration, sludge age, or a toxic load.
Maintenance and calibration
- Clean the probe or the sample system on the schedule the fouling rate sets; a plant with grease cleans weekly.
- Compare with a laboratory grab sample taken at the probe on a schedule, and adjust the matrix calibration when the difference exceeds the tolerance written in the procedure.
- Replace reagents and standards in date; an expired standard calibrates the analyzer to a wrong value.
- Replace membranes and electrodes on the manufacturer interval or when the slope fails; keep spares.
- Log every cleaning, calibration, and replacement; the drift record decides the schedule.
- Check the temperature and pH compensation values against independent instruments; a bad pH electrode in the probe body makes the ammonia wrong.
Frequently asked questions
- Probe or analyzer for aeration control?
- A probe in most cases: the loop needs a fast, continuous trend more than absolute accuracy, and the probe sits where the process is. Calibrate it against the laboratory weekly and clean it. An analyzer is chosen when the plant also needs a compliance-grade number from the same instrument.
- Why does the probe read high at low ammonia?
- Potassium. At low ammonium, the potassium response is a large fraction of the signal, and a probe without potassium compensation, or with a failed potassium electrode, reads high. Check the potassium electrode and the compensation setting.
- How often does the wet-chemistry analyzer need attention?
- Reagents monthly or so depending on the cycle rate, the sample filter weekly to monthly depending on the water, and a full service a few times a year. A plant that budgets no technician time for it will have a very expensive alarm generator.
- Can I use the same analyzer for the aeration basin and the effluent?
- With a sample switching system and a range that covers both, yes, at the cost of a slower update on each stream and a more complex sample system. For control on the aeration basin, a dedicated probe is usually better and the analyzer serves the effluent.
Related topics
- Dissolved Oxygen MeasurementOptical and membrane DO sensors for aeration control: how each measures, why optical has taken over, air calibration with pressure and salinity corrections, sensor placement in an aeration basin, fouling and cleaning, and the response time that limits the control loop.
- pH MeasurementGlass electrodes, reference junctions, and why pH is the measurement that drifts: how the sensor works, temperature compensation, two-point buffer calibration, mounting rules, the failure modes of the reference, and using the signal for chemical feed control.
- Chlorine Residual AnalyzersAmperometric and colorimetric residual analyzers: what each measures, free versus total chlorine, pH and flow dependence, sample line design, calibration against a DPD grab sample, and using the signal for feed control.
- Nitrate AnalyzersOnline nitrate measurement: ultraviolet absorbance probes and analyzers, ion-selective electrodes, and wet chemistry, the interferences from organics, turbidity, and chloride, the uses in denitrification and source monitoring, and maintenance.
- Calibration ProceduresHow a utility calibrates its instruments consistently: the as-found and as-left discipline, tolerance from the loop rather than the data sheet, the reference standard and its traceability, the five-point check with hysteresis, adjusting only when needed, intervals set from history, and the procedure written once per instrument type.
- Calibration DocumentationThe records a calibration program produces and what each is for: the calibration certificate per event, the instrument history, the reference standard file, the schedule, the tolerance and interval register, and how the records are organized so a regulator, an auditor, or the next technician can find what they need.
Direct contact
Have a controls question?
Reach Eric Sullivan directly about anything on this site, a controls or automation topic, or one of his personal projects.