The short answer
Concentrate Systems
Every gallon of permeate leaves a fraction of a gallon of concentrate, carrying the salts and whatever else the membranes removed at several times the feed concentration, and the concentrate has to go somewhere the permit allows. The concentrate valve on the skid sets the concentrate flow and therefore the recovery, and it is the first control; after it, the concentrate is metered, monitored for conductivity and sometimes pH and other parameters, and routed to its disposal: a surface water outfall under a discharge permit, often with degasification or aeration and pH adjustment first; a sewer under an industrial discharge agreement; a deep injection well with its own pressure, flow, and annulus monitoring; evaporation ponds or, rarely, a zero liquid discharge process. Each route has flow limits, quality limits, and reporting requirements that become setpoints, alarms, and historian records, and the concentrate system is often where a membrane plant fails its permit rather than at the permeate.
Key points
- The concentrate valve sets recovery; its position loop is slow and interacts with the permeate flow loop.
- Meter and monitor the concentrate: flow, conductivity, pH, and whatever the permit names, with the records kept.
- Disposal routes each have controls: outfall diffuser and pretreatment, sewer discharge agreement limits, injection well pressure and annulus, ponds and their levels.
- Degasification for sulfide and carbon dioxide, and pH adjustment, where the permit requires them before discharge.
- Alarm on flow and quality limits before they become permit exceedances; the historian is the compliance record.
At the skid
The concentrate leaves the last stage through a control valve that holds the concentrate flow at the value that gives the design recovery. The valve sees the highest pressure in the plant on one side and near atmospheric on the other, so it is a severe-service valve with cavitation control, and its position loop is tuned slowly so that it does not fight the permeate flow loop. A pressure sustaining valve or an orifice downstream may hold backpressure on the last stage. The concentrate flowmeter is the second half of the recovery calculation and is checked against the permeate meter and the feed meter, because a recovery calculated from a bad meter scales the last elements.
Monitoring
| Parameter | Why | Typical requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Flow | Permit limit; mass balance; recovery | Continuous, totalized, reported |
| Conductivity or total dissolved solids | Discharge limit; mass loading | Continuous with alarm; laboratory confirmation |
| pH | Discharge range; corrosion in the disposal piping | Continuous where required; adjustment loop |
| Dissolved oxygen, sulfide, or specific ions | Outfall permits on sensitive waters | Analyzers or laboratory per permit |
| Temperature | Some permits | Continuous |
| Radionuclides, metals, or other constituents | Where the source water carries them | Laboratory sampling on the permit schedule |
Disposal routes
- Surface water outfall
- Discharge to a river, estuary, or ocean through a diffuser under a permit that limits flow, salinity, pH, dissolved oxygen, and toxicity. Pretreatment often includes degasification to strip hydrogen sulfide and carbon dioxide, aeration to raise dissolved oxygen, and pH adjustment. The controls run the degasifier, the aeration, and the pH loop, and hold the discharge within its limits with alarms and a divert.
- Sewer
- Discharge to a wastewater collection system under an agreement that limits flow, total dissolved solids, and pH so that the treatment plant is not upset. The controls meter the flow, hold pH, and alarm on the agreement limits; a storage tank may buffer the discharge to off-peak hours for the treatment plant.
- Deep well injection
- Injection below the drinking water aquifers into a confined zone under a permit. The controls hold the injection pressure below the permit maximum, meter the flow, monitor the annulus pressure that proves the well casing is intact, and alarm on any deviation; a loss of annulus pressure or a rise in injection pressure stops injection and the plant.
- Evaporation ponds
- In dry climates; the controls are pond level, freeboard, and the transfer between ponds, with leak detection monitoring under the liner.
- Zero liquid discharge
- Evaporators and crystallizers that turn the concentrate into solids; an industrial process with its own control system, rare in municipal plants because of cost.
Injection wells
An injection well is a regulated structure with a tubing string inside a casing and a sealed annulus between them, and the annulus pressure is the proof that neither has leaked. The controls monitor the injection pressure at the wellhead against the permit maximum, the flow and its total, the annulus pressure against its allowed range, and the annulus fluid level or volume; a deviation alarms and, beyond limits, stops the injection pumps and the membrane trains that feed them. Mechanical integrity tests on the well schedule are recorded, and the historian keeps every reading for the permit reports. A concentrate storage tank between the plant and the well lets the trains run through a short well outage and lets injection be steady rather than following train starts.
Alarms and records
- Flow above the permit limit or the disposal capacity: alarm, then reduce plant production.
- Quality outside the permit range: alarm, divert to storage where possible, then stop.
- Injection pressure or annulus deviation: alarm, then stop injection.
- Degasifier or aeration failure: alarm; discharge stops if the permit depends on it.
- Every parameter the permit names, historized at the resolution the permit implies, with the totalizers and the daily values reported from the historian.
Frequently asked questions
- Why is the concentrate valve so hard on itself?
- It drops the full membrane pressure to near atmospheric in one step, which cavitates and erodes an ordinary valve. Severe-service trim, staged pressure drop, or a valve plus an orifice are the answers, and the valve is on the maintenance schedule regardless.
- Can I discharge the concentrate to the plant drain?
- Only where the permit or the sewer agreement allows the flow and the salinity, which is rare for a plant of any size. The concentrate is a regulated discharge whatever pipe it enters.
- The annulus pressure on the injection well is slowly falling.
- A leak in the tubing or the packer, a temperature effect, or a slow loss through the annulus system. It is reported to the regulator per the permit and investigated with a mechanical integrity test; injection may have to stop. Never top up the annulus to hide the trend.
- How much concentrate storage do I need?
- Enough to ride through the longest expected disposal outage at full production, or to allow steady injection through train starts and stops, whichever is larger. The tank has level control, overflow alarms, and its own permit conditions.
Related topics
- Reverse OsmosisReverse osmosis from the controls side: what the skid contains, the instruments that matter, the numbers an operator watches, recovery, rejection, normalized permeate flow, and the trends that say when the membranes need cleaning or replacement.
- Membrane ControlThe control system of a membrane skid: the loops for permeate flow, recovery, and dosing, the permissives and trips, the start, run, flush, and shutdown sequences, and the data the operators and the membrane supplier need from the historian.
- NanofiltrationNanofiltration from the controls side: how it differs from reverse osmosis in pressure, recovery, and what it removes, the softening and color removal applications where it dominates, and trends that are shared with reverse osmosis and the ones that differ.
- ConductivityConductivity measurement in water systems: what it indicates, contacting and inductive sensors, cell constants and ranges, temperature compensation, the relation to total dissolved solids, uses from membrane monitoring to blending, and fouling problems.
- EPA Rules and Their Control System ImplicationsThe federal environmental agency rules that shape what a water or wastewater control system must measure, record, and report: the surface water rules, residual and byproduct rules, groundwater and lead rules, discharge permits, and record retention.
- Reporting from the HistorianTurning history into the reports a utility must produce: the monthly operating report, compliance reports for the regulator, daily operator summaries, pump run and energy reports, the calculations behind daily minimums, maximums, and totals, handling bad quality and gaps, and building reports once so they run every month without an engineer.
Direct contact
Have a controls question?
Reach Eric Sullivan directly about anything on this site, a controls or automation topic, or one of his personal projects.