The short answer
Heat Kills Panels Slowly
A control panel runs hotter than the air around it by the heat its own components make, and an outdoor panel in the sun adds a solar load on top. Every electronic component in it has a rated ambient, usually 40 to 60 °C, and above that its life shortens fast; electrolytic capacitors, which are in every power supply and drive, lose roughly half their life for each 10 °C rise. The remedies, in order of value, are to keep the sun off the enclosure, move the drives out or size the enclosure for their losses, cool it with a filtered fan only where the outside air is cooler and clean, and otherwise fit an air conditioner or heat exchanger sized from a heat calculation. Put a temperature sensor inside and alarm it.
Key points
- Drives are the largest heat source in most panels: two to four percent of their rating is lost as heat inside the enclosure.
- Electrolytic capacitor life roughly halves for every 10 °C rise, so a panel that runs 20 °C too hot uses up its power supplies four times as fast.
- Sun on a dark enclosure adds more heat than the components in many outdoor panels; shade is the cheapest cooling there is.
- A filtered fan only helps when the outside air is cooler and the filter is maintained; in a Florida August it is neither.
- A temperature transmitter inside the panel, trended and alarmed, is the only way to know what the panel actually sees.
The lift station panel had two 25 horsepower drives, a controller, a radio, and a 24 volt power supply in a stainless enclosure on a concrete pad with no shade in any direction. It had failed a power supply in its third summer, a drive in its fifth, and the controller in its seventh, and each failure had been treated as a bad part. The panel had a thermometer in it for a week after the third failure. It read 71 °C at three in the afternoon, which is above the rated ambient of everything inside it. Nothing had been bad. Everything had been cooked.
Where the heat comes from
A panel is a box that generates heat inside and, outdoors, absorbs it from outside. The inside sources are easy to list. A variable frequency drive wastes two to four percent of the power passing through it, so a pair of 25 horsepower drives at full load put something like a kilowatt into the enclosure. A switching power supply is about ninety percent efficient, so a 240 watt supply adds around 25 watts. Contactor coils, relays, breakers under load, transformers, and the controller add tens of watts each. The outside source is the sun: a dark or unpainted metal enclosure in direct sun absorbs heat across its whole sunlit face, and on a summer afternoon that can exceed the internal load of a modest panel. Light colors and shade change that number more than anything inside the box.
| Source | Typical heat into the enclosure | Note |
|---|---|---|
| VFD, per horsepower of load | About 20 to 30 W | Roughly 2 to 4 percent of the drive rating at full load |
| Switching power supply | About 10 percent of its output | A 240 W supply adds around 25 W |
| Control transformer | A few percent of its rating | Continuous even at light load |
| Contactor or relay coil | 5 to 15 W each while energized | Adds up across a duplex or triplex station |
| PLC with I/O | 10 to 40 W | Depends on rack size and outputs |
| Sun on a dark enclosure | Can exceed the internal load | Depends on orientation, color, and season |
What it costs each component
Electronic components have a rated ambient, the temperature of the air they expect around them, and it is lower than most people assume. Many drives are rated for 40 °C ambient at full output and must be derated above it. Power supplies and controllers are often rated for 55 or 60 °C and derated above 50. Those numbers are for the air inside the enclosure, next to the component, which is warmer than the room and much warmer than the air outside. Below the rated ambient, life is a function of temperature all the same. The electrolytic capacitors in every power supply and drive follow a rule of thumb: for every 10 °C the temperature rises, their life halves. A supply that would last ten years at 45 °C lasts five at 55 and about two and a half at 65. The lift station panel at 71 °C was consuming its power supplies at roughly six times the rate its designer would have expected, and the failure history matched.
- Drives
- Derate above their rated ambient and fault on overtemperature when pushed further; before that, the DC bus capacitors age. A drive that trips on overtemperature on the hottest days is telling you about the enclosure, not the drive.
- Power supplies
- Lose output capacity with heat and lose life through their capacitors. A supply that fails after a few summers has usually not been defective.
- Controllers
- Rated for a wide range, but the same capacitors are inside, and the battery or memory retention is shortened by heat.
- Relays and contactors
- Coil resistance rises with temperature, so the pull-in margin shrinks; a coil that chatters on a hot afternoon is running near its limit.
- Breakers
- Thermal-magnetic breakers trip earlier when hot. A breaker that trips nuisance-style only in summer is derating itself.
- Radios and modems
- Often the lowest rated components in the panel, and the first to drop out on a hot day.
The heat calculation
Enclosure manufacturers publish the method, and it is simple enough for a small utility to do by hand. Add up the watts dissipated inside. Compute the enclosure surface area that can shed heat, which is the surface not against a wall or the ground. The temperature rise of a sealed enclosure is the internal watts divided by the product of the area and a heat transfer figure for the enclosure material and finish, which the manufacturer tabulates. If the result, added to the highest outdoor temperature the panel will see plus a solar allowance, exceeds the lowest rated ambient of anything inside, the panel needs a bigger enclosure, less heat in it, or active cooling. The calculation is short and it is the one step that turns the choice of a cooling method from a guess into an answer.
Temperature rise (°C) ≈ Internal heat (W) ÷ (Effective surface area (m²) × Heat transfer coefficient (W/m²·°C))
- T
- h
- e
- c
- o
- e
- f
- f
- i
- c
- i
- e
- n
- t
- c
- o
- m
- e
- s
- f
- r
- o
- m
- t
- h
- e
- e
- n
- c
- l
- o
- s
- u
- r
- e
- m
- a
- n
- u
- f
- a
- c
- t
- u
- r
- e
- r
- ;
- a
- b
- o
- u
- t
- 5
- .
- 5
- f
- o
- r
- p
- a
- i
- n
- t
- e
- d
- s
- t
- e
- e
- l
- i
- s
- a
- c
- o
- m
- m
- o
- n
- p
- l
- a
- n
- n
- i
- n
- g
- f
- i
- g
- u
- r
- e
- .
- A
- d
- d
- t
- h
- e
- o
- u
- t
- d
- o
- o
- r
- m
- a
- x
- i
- m
- u
- m
- a
- n
- d
- a
- s
- o
- l
- a
- r
- a
- l
- l
- o
- w
- a
- n
- c
- e
- t
- o
- g
- e
- t
- t
- h
- e
- i
- n
- s
- i
- d
- e
- t
- e
- m
- p
- e
- r
- a
- t
- u
- r
- e
- .
What to do about it, in order
- 1
Shade
A sunshield or a shade structure removes the solar load, the largest single input for an outdoor panel, at the lowest cost of any option. Orienting the door away from the afternoon sun helps too.
- 2
Take the heat out of the box
Mount the drives in their own ventilated enclosure or in a shaded location, or specify drives with through-panel heatsinks that put most of the loss outside. This is the single largest reduction available in a pump panel.
- 3
Size the enclosure for the load
A larger enclosure has more surface to shed heat through. If the calculation says the rise is too high, going up a size is often cheaper than cooling.
- 4
Filtered fan, only when it works
A fan draws in outside air, so it only helps when outside air is cooler than the target and clean enough for the filter to survive. It changes the enclosure rating, needs filter service, and does nothing on the days that matter in a hot, humid climate.
- 5
Heat exchanger or air conditioner
A closed-loop air-to-air heat exchanger keeps the enclosure sealed and works when outside air is cooler. An enclosure air conditioner works when it is not, and it is the right answer for a drive panel in full sun in the South. Size it from the calculation with margin, and include its maintenance in the schedule.
Measure it
A temperature sensor inside the panel, wired to a spare analog input and trended in SCADA, costs less than one power supply and answers every question in this article for that panel. Alarm it at a value below the lowest rated ambient inside, with a delay so a hot afternoon does not page anyone, and trend it against the outside temperature. The trend shows whether the cooling keeps up, whether the filter has loaded, and whether the air conditioner has quietly quit. The lift station panel got a sunshield, its drives moved to a ventilated drive enclosure, and a sensor. It has run at under 45 °C inside on the worst afternoons since, and it has not failed a component in the four summers after.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a stainless enclosure better or worse for heat?
- Stainless sheds internal heat slightly less well than painted steel and, unpainted, absorbs less sun than a dark finish but more than a white one. The difference is small compared with shade and with what is inside. Choose stainless for corrosion and deal with heat separately.
- Can we just leave the door open on hot days?
- It lowers the temperature and removes every rating the enclosure has, exposes energized parts, and invites water, insects, and rodents. It is a diagnosis, not a fix: if opening the door is the only way the panel survives, the panel needs cooling.
- What temperature should the alarm be set at?
- Below the lowest rated ambient of any component inside, with some margin: often 50 °C for a panel with drives rated at 40 that are already derated, or 55 for a controls-only panel. Check the datasheets; the alarm should fire before anything is outside its rating.
- Do heaters matter as well?
- Yes, for condensation and for cold-rated components in winter. An enclosure heater with a thermostat keeps the inside above the dew point, which prevents the corrosion and tracking that a cold, damp panel develops. Heat in summer and heat in winter are two different problems in the same box.
Related topics
- Enclosure Heat CalculationsEstimating the temperature inside a control panel from the power its contents dissipate and the surface that carries it out, what to do when the answer is too hot, and why drives change everything.
- Enclosure SelectionChoosing the box: NEMA and UL 50 type ratings, materials for corrosive and outdoor sites, sizing for heat and wire bending space, and the details at the conduit entries and the door that decide whether the rating survives installation.
- Panel OverheatingA panel that runs hot: drives tripping on temperature in the afternoon, controllers faulting in summer, components discolored, a fan that never stops. The causes from an undersized enclosure to a clogged filter, measuring the rise, and the fixes.
- Panel Power SuppliesThe 24 V DC supply behind everything in a modern panel: sizing with real inrush and duty, single versus redundant with diode modules, how a switch-mode supply behaves under a short, distribution and fusing per branch, monitoring, and the failure modes that take out a whole panel at once.
- How to Size an EnclosureSize a control panel enclosure so that everything fits, cools, and can be worked on: lay out the components with their clearances and wireway, add the spare space the plant will need, and mounting before ordering.
- UL 508A Industrial Control PanelsWhat the listing actually covers, what has to appear on the label, and the requirements that most often cause a panel to fail inspection.
Direct contact
Have a controls question?
Reach Eric Sullivan directly about anything on this site, a controls or automation topic, or one of his personal projects.