The short answer
VFD Control for Water Pumping
A variable frequency drive lets a pump run at the speed the system needs instead of the speed the motor happens to have, and on a system with mostly friction head that saves a great deal of energy, because power falls with the cube of speed while flow falls only in proportion. On a system with mostly static head, a well lifting water to a tank or a booster feeding a hill, the pump must run near full speed to make any flow at all, and the savings shrink to the point where a constant speed pump with an alternation scheme may cost less to own. The control is a loop on pressure, flow, or level that sets the speed, bounded by a minimum speed below which the pump makes no useful flow and a maximum at the motor rating, with several drives sharing the load at equal speed when one is not enough. The drive brings its own needs: an inverter-rated motor, cable length limits or filters, harmonic mitigation on a weak service, and heat in the panel, all of which are part of the decision.
Key points
- Savings come from friction head; static head forces the pump toward full speed and eats the savings.
- Minimum speed is set by the static head and the pump curve, not by the drive; below it the pump churns.
- Control on pressure, flow, or level with one loop setting the speed and limits on both ends.
- Run parallel pumps at the same speed; add a pump when the running ones reach maximum, remove one at minimum.
- Count the motor, the cable, the harmonics, and the panel heat in the cost before deciding.
The affinity laws and their limit
Q₂ ÷ Q₁ = N₂ ÷ N₁; H₂ ÷ H₁ = (N₂ ÷ N₁)²; P₂ ÷ P₁ = (N₂ ÷ N₁)³
- Q = flow, H = head, P = power, N = speed
- These describe one pump at two speeds on the same system curve; the system decides where the pump actually runs
The cube law is the promise: half speed, an eighth of the power. It holds when the system curve passes near the origin, which is a system of pipe friction with little elevation change. When the system has static head, the pump at reduced speed produces less head, and at some speed it produces exactly the static head and no flow. Between full speed and that point the pump runs on a steep part of its curve, its efficiency falls, and the power saving is a fraction of the cube law. The savings estimate must be made on the actual system curve with the actual duty profile, not on the affinity laws alone.
N_min ≈ N_rated × √(H_static ÷ H_shutoff)
- N_min = the speed at which the pump just reaches the static head with no flow
- H_static = static head of the system
- H_shutoff = pump shutoff head at rated speed
- Practical minimum speed is somewhat above this so the pump delivers useful flow with acceptable efficiency
| System | Static head share | Speed range with useful flow | Savings prospect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Distribution booster on flat terrain | Low | Wide | Large; pressure control pays quickly |
| Booster to an elevated zone | High | Narrow, near full speed | Small; consider constant speed with a pressure-reducing or alternation scheme |
| Well pump to a ground tank | High | Narrow | Small; the drive mainly softens starts and trims flow |
| High service pump to a system with storage | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate; depends on the storage and the demand profile |
| Plant internal transfer | Low to moderate | Wide | Good; flow control replaces throttling |
Control loops
- Pressure control
- A pressure transmitter at the discharge or at a remote point sets the speed to hold a setpoint; the standard booster loop. A remote pressure transmitter, or a setpoint that rises with flow, compensates for friction so that the far end of the system sees constant pressure.
- Flow control
- A flowmeter sets the speed to hold a flow setpoint; used for transfer, filter feed, and flow-paced processes. Ramp limits prevent surges.
- Level control
- A tank or wet well level sets the speed so that inflow matches outflow, or the speed holds a level band; softer on the system than on and off pumping.
- Limits
- A minimum speed from the static head calculation, a maximum at the motor rating, a minimum flow or a no-flow detection that stops the pump at minimum speed, and a discharge pressure high limit.
Several pumps
When one pump at maximum speed cannot meet the demand, a second is started and both run at the same speed, because two pumps at different speeds on one header fight and the slower one delivers little. The loop then controls the common speed. When the pumps together fall to a speed where one could do the work, one is stopped, with hysteresis and minimum run and stop times so that the staging does not hunt. Each pump on its own drive is the flexible arrangement; one drive with constant speed pumps beside it is cheaper and works when the drive pump can span the gaps.
What the drive brings with it
- An inverter-duty motor, or an existing motor checked for insulation and bearing suitability; a shaft grounding ring on larger motors.
- Cable length limits from the drive to the motor, or an output filter for long runs to a well or a remote pump.
- Harmonics on the supply; a line reactor or a low-harmonic drive where the service or the generator is weak.
- Heat in the panel, a few percent of the drive rating, in the enclosure heat calculation.
- A bypass contactor or a spare drive where the pump must run when the drive fails.
- Drive faults and diagnostics on the network, and a drive noise plan for the instrument wiring.
Estimating before buying
- 1
Get the duty profile
Flow against hours from the historian or a logger, for a year if possible.
- 2
Draw the system curve
Static head plus friction, from the hydraulic model or a field test at two flows.
- 3
Find the operating points
Pump speed and power at each flow in the profile on the actual curve.
- 4
Compare
Energy per year against the existing arrangement, including a throttling valve if one exists.
- 5
Add the costs
Drive, motor, filter, panel changes, harmonic mitigation, and maintenance; and the benefits beyond energy, soft starting, surge reduction, and process control.
Frequently asked questions
- Why does the pump vibrate and heat up at low speed?
- Below the minimum speed the pump makes little or no flow and churns the water in its casing, heating it and running off its curve. Raise the minimum speed setting to where the pump delivers flow, and stop the pump instead of running it below that.
- Should every pump have a drive?
- Not necessarily. One drive pump for trimming with constant speed pumps for base load is a common and economical arrangement where the drive pump can cover the gaps between stages. Every pump on a drive gives the most flexibility and the most equipment.
- How much energy will a drive save on a well?
- Often little, because a well pump lifts against a large static head and must run near full speed. The drive earns its place on a well by soft starting, by trimming flow to a treatment rate, and by reducing water hammer, not by energy.
- Can I retrofit a drive on an existing motor?
- Often, with the motor checked for insulation class and bearing protection, the cable length considered, and a filter added if needed. Older motors and long cable runs are the cases that fail; the motor manufacturer guidance and a drive vendor review settle it.
Related topics
- Variable Frequency Drives in Pump PanelsWhat a drive adds to a pump panel and what it costs: speed control, soft start, reduced inrush, and diagnostics against heat, harmonics, cable and motor stress, bypass, and the minimum speed below which a pump does no work.
- Distribution Pressure ControlHow a booster or high service pump station holds discharge pressure with variable speed pumps, how pumps are staged, and what stops the system hunting.
- Flow Control in Water PumpingControlling the flow a pumping system delivers: speed against valves, flow-paced pumping to a treatment rate, the flow loop with its ramp limits and its meter placement, and the loop tuning that keeps a flow controller steady.
- VFD Pump Control in WastewaterThe control modes for a variable speed wastewater pump: level control, flow pacing, fixed speed with soft start, and drawdown modes, plus the wastewater-specific rules: minimum speed, ragging at low speed, force main velocity, and the periodic full-speed run.
- Motor Will Not Reach SpeedA drive that runs but never gets the motor to the commanded speed: the reference and its scaling, the maximum frequency and speed limits, current limit holding the ramp, a load beyond the motor, a wrong motor parameter set, and a low supply, with the drive readouts that separate them.
- PID Control for Pumps and ValvesWhat each term actually does, how to tune a loop on a real pump station, and the handful of mistakes that cause most of the oscillation people blame on tuning.
Direct contact
Have a controls question?
Reach Eric Sullivan directly about anything on this site, a controls or automation topic, or one of his personal projects.