Symptom
Lights dim or flicker when a motor starts; contactors drop out and reseal; the controller resets or logs a power dip; drives trip on undervoltage or DC bus low; the HMI restarts; it is worse on generator power or at the end of a long feeder.
The short answer
Voltage Sag on Motor Start
An induction motor started across the line draws six to eight times its full load current for the seconds it takes to reach speed, and that current through the impedance of the source produces a voltage sag proportional to it. On a stiff utility service the sag is a few percent and nobody notices; on a small transformer, a long feeder, a generator, or through a corroded connection it can reach twenty or thirty percent, which drops contactor coils, resets controllers, and faults drives on undervoltage. The sag is measured with a recorder through a start, the source is checked by comparing the starting current with the transformer size and the feeder length, and the fix is to reduce the starting current with a soft starter or a drive, to stiffen the source with a larger transformer or feeder or a properly sized generator, to repair any bad connection, and to give the controls ride-through so that the remaining sag does not reach them.
Key points
- Across-the-line starting draws six to eight times full load current; the source impedance turns it into a sag.
- Record the sag through a start: depth and duration decide what drops out.
- A sag over ten percent at the panel is a source problem: transformer, feeder, generator, or a connection.
- Reduce the starting current with a soft starter or a drive; it is the fix that works on any source.
- Give the controls ride-through so that the sag that remains does not reset anything.
Possible causes and what to check
| Possible cause | What to check |
|---|---|
| Across-the-line start on a source too small for the motor | Starting current against the transformer rating; a motor whose starting current approaches the transformer rating sags the bus badly. Compute or measure. |
| Long or undersized feeder | Voltage drop along the feeder at starting current; measure the sag at the panel and at the service and compare. |
| Generator marginal for the motor start | The sag appears only on generator; the generator sizing against the motor starting requirement and the regulator response. |
| Loose or corroded connection in the power path | A sag larger than the calculation predicts; a warm termination on a thermal scan under load. |
| Several motors starting together | The sag when two start at once; the sequence logic staggers them. |
| Motor or driven load harder to start than designed | A pump starting against a closed valve or a seized bearing draws starting current longer; the start time has grown. |
| Utility service weak or a transformer tap wrong | The nominal voltage low before the start; the sag then reaches the drop-out level sooner. Check the steady voltage and the tap. |
| Controls without ride-through | A sag of modest depth that a UPS or a constant voltage transformer would have absorbed. Check what the controls are fed from. |
Measure
- 1
Record a start
A power quality recorder or a logging meter on the panel bus, capturing minimum voltage and current through a start. Note the depth in percent and the duration in seconds.
- 2
Record at the service
The same at the service entrance or the transformer secondary. A sag at the panel much larger than at the service is the feeder or a connection between them.
- 3
Record on generator
If the site has one, the same start on generator power.
- 4
Note what drops
Which contactors, controllers, and drives react, and at what depth. Coils drop around a quarter to a third below rated voltage; drives fault at their undervoltage setting.
Estimate the source
Sag, percent ≈ 100 × I_start × Z_source / V
- I_start = motor starting current, roughly six to eight times full load current for an across-the-line start
- Z_source = the impedance of the transformer plus the feeder, from the transformer impedance and the conductor data
- V = the line voltage
A 50 horsepower motor with a full load current near 65 amps at 480 volts draws around 400 amps starting; on a 75 kVA transformer with 4 percent impedance, whose full load current is about 90 amps, that starting current is more than four times the transformer rating and the sag at the transformer alone approaches 15 to 20 percent before the feeder is counted. The same motor on a 300 kVA transformer sags a few percent. The arithmetic says whether the source was ever adequate.
Fixes
| Fix | What it does | When |
|---|---|---|
| Soft starter | Ramps the voltage, limiting starting current to two or three times full load | Pumps and fans on any source; the common first choice |
| Variable frequency drive | Starts at low frequency, drawing little more than full load current, and gives speed control | When speed control is useful anyway, or the source is very weak |
| Larger transformer or feeder | Lowers the source impedance | When the source is undersized for the plant, not just the one motor |
| Generator sized for motor starting | A generator with the starting kVA and a fast regulator | Sites on generator where the sag occurs only on generator |
| Repair the connection | Removes the added impedance | Whenever the thermal scan finds one |
| Stagger the starts | One motor starting at a time | Multiple motors; logic in the controller |
| Ride-through for the controls | A UPS, a constant voltage transformer, DC coils, drive undervoltage settings | Always, for the sag that remains |
Generator sites
A generator sized for the running load of a lift station starts the first pump and sags badly when the second starts, because a generator has far higher impedance than a utility transformer and its regulator takes cycles to respond. Generator sizing for motor starting uses the starting kVA of the largest motor with the others running, and the controller logic on generator power starts pumps one at a time with a delay. A soft starter on each pump reduces the generator size the site needs and is often cheaper than the larger generator.
Frequently asked questions
- The utility says our service is fine. Why the sag?
- The service may be fine at the transformer and the sag is in the feeder to the panel or a connection along it, or the transformer is adequate for the running load and not for the start. Measure at both ends and do the arithmetic; the answer is usually inside the fence.
- Will a soft starter fix drives faulting on the sag?
- It reduces the sag at its source, which helps everything. The drives also have an undervoltage trip level and a ride-through setting in their parameters; set them per the manual for the sag that remains.
- The sag only happens on generator. Is the generator too small?
- For motor starting, probably. Generators are often sized on running kilowatts and not on starting kVA, and the regulator response adds to the sag. Options are a soft starter on the pumps, a start sequence that staggers them, or a generator sized for the start.
- Can the sag damage anything?
- Contactors that drop and reseal under load arc their contacts; motors that lose their contactor mid-start restart against rotation; drives that trip repeatedly stress their bus; controllers that reset lose retentive data. Over years the sag costs contactors, drives, and outages; the fix pays.
Related topics
- Soft StartersReduced-voltage solid-state starters: how they ramp a motor, what they do for inrush, water hammer, and mechanical stress, where they beat a drive and where they do not, bypass contactors, and the settings that matter on a pump.
- Variable Frequency Drives in Pump PanelsWhat a drive adds to a pump panel and what it costs: speed control, soft start, reduced inrush, and diagnostics against heat, harmonics, cable and motor stress, bypass, and the minimum speed below which a pump does no work.
- Loss of Control VoltageControl voltage that drops out for a moment and comes back, resetting controllers and dropping contactors: utility sags when a large load starts, a transfer switch operation, a loose neutral, or an overloaded control transformer. Catching it with a recorder.
- Generator Transfer ProblemsThe generator started and something still went wrong: no transfer, controls reset during the gap, drives faulted, pumps ran backward, or the retransfer caused a second outage. The sequence and its timers, neutral and rotation, and the monthly test.
- Drive Will Not Start in AUTOThe drive runs from the keypad or in HAND but not from the controller. The command source, the enable and safe torque off inputs, the speed reference, and the network control word, checked in the order that finds the problem fastest.
- Relay ChatterA relay or contactor that buzzes, cycles, or will not stay pulled in: low coil voltage from an overloaded supply or a sag, an AC coil with a dirty armature or broken shading ring, a solid-state output leaking, or an input bouncing at its threshold.
Direct contact
Have a controls question?
Reach Eric Sullivan directly about anything on this site, a controls or automation topic, or one of his personal projects.