Symptom
A breaker or a supplementary protector trips at power-up, when a drive or a transformer is energized, after running for a time, in hot weather, or at random, and no short or ground fault is found; the load current measured at rest is within the rating.
The short answer
Nuisance Breaker Trips
A breaker that trips repeatedly with no fault found is usually responding to something short and large, or something long and modest, that its curve was not chosen for: inrush current at energizing from a transformer, a drive charging its bus, or a switching supply, which trips a breaker with a low instantaneous setting; a circuit whose running load has crept above the rating as loads were added; a breaker of the wrong curve for the load; a breaker whose thermal element has been weakened by heat, by repeated trips, or by a loose terminal heating it; harmonic currents that a true-reading breaker sees and a meter does not; or a real ground fault on a breaker that trips on one. Record when it trips, clamp the load with a meter that captures inrush and reads true current, read the breaker curve, and fix by the right curve and rating, by moving loads, by tightening the terminal, or by replacing the breaker.
Key points
- Inrush trips the instantaneous element; overload trips the thermal element; the timing says which.
- Read the curve: the breaker type and its trip curve against the load inrush and running current.
- A breaker that has tripped many times, or that sits in a hot panel, trips early; replace it.
- A loose terminal heats the breaker from outside and trips it without an overload.
- The fix is the right curve and rating, or less load, never a bigger breaker on the same wire.
Possible causes and what to check
| Possible cause | What to check |
|---|---|
| Inrush at energizing against a breaker with a low instantaneous setting | Trips at power-up or when the transformer, drive, or supply is switched on; holds afterward. Capture the inrush with a meter that records it; compare with the curve. |
| Running load above the rating after additions | Trips after minutes or hours. Clamp the circuit with everything on and compare with the rating; list what was added. |
| Wrong trip curve for the load | A fast curve on a motor or transformer circuit. Read the curve letter or the trip settings against the load type. |
| Breaker weakened by heat or repeated trips | Trips at lower current than its rating in a hot panel or after many trips. Replace it and correct the heat. |
| Loose terminal heating the breaker | The breaker is warm or discolored at one terminal; a thermal image shows it. Torque the terminals; replace a damaged breaker. |
| Harmonic current from drives and switching supplies | A true-reading clamp shows more current than an average-reading meter; the neutral carries more than expected. Size for true current; address the harmonics. |
| A real ground fault on a breaker that detects ground faults | The trip indicator shows ground fault. Find the fault as for any ground fault. |
| Motor starting on a circuit shared with other loads | Trips when the motor starts. Give the motor its own protection sized for starting. |
| Undersized wire raising the temperature at the breaker | The conductor is warm; the ampacity is below the breaker rating. Correct the conductor or the breaker. |
When does it trip
| Timing | Element | Likely cause |
|---|---|---|
| Instantly at energizing | Instantaneous | Inrush against a low setting or a fast curve |
| Within seconds of a start | Instantaneous or short-time | Motor starting current; a shared circuit |
| After minutes to hours | Thermal | Overload; a hot panel; a weakened breaker; a loose terminal |
| Only on hot days | Thermal | Ambient derating; the panel heat problem |
| At random with no pattern | Either | Intermittent fault; a failing breaker; harmonics under changing load |
| With a ground fault indication | Ground fault | A real fault to find |
Procedure
- 1
Record
When it trips, what was starting, the weather, the trip indicator if the breaker has one.
- 2
Measure
The running current with a true-reading clamp; the inrush with a meter that captures it; the temperature of the breaker and its terminals under load.
- 3
Read the breaker
Its type, its rating, its curve, its ambient rating, its age and trip history.
- 4
Compare
The inrush against the instantaneous trip; the running current against the rating derated for the panel temperature; the load type against the curve.
- 5
Inspect
The terminals for looseness and discoloration; the conductor size; what else is on the circuit.
- 6
Fix
The right curve and rating for the load on a conductor that carries it; loads moved; terminals torqued; a breaker replaced if weakened or heated.
Curves
Supplementary protectors and small breakers come in curves that set where the instantaneous trip begins: a fast curve trips at a few times rated current and suits resistive and electronic loads; a medium curve at several times and suits general control circuits; a slow curve at higher multiples and suits transformers, motors, and drives whose inrush is large and brief. A transformer on a fast curve trips at every energizing; a fast curve on a drive input trips as the bus capacitors charge. The curve is chosen for the load in the design, and a replacement breaker of the wrong curve is a nuisance trip that appears after maintenance.
The listing question
In an industrial control panel, the device that protects a circuit is either a listed circuit breaker or a supplementary protector, and they are not interchangeable: a supplementary protector is not permitted as branch circuit protection in most cases, and it has a lower interrupting rating. A nuisance trip on a supplementary protector used where a breaker belongs is a design finding as well as a nuisance, and the replacement is the listed device the standard requires.
Frequently asked questions
- The breaker trips when the drive is powered up. Is the drive faulty?
- Usually not; the drive draws a large inrush to charge its bus capacitors, and a fast-curve breaker or one with a low instantaneous setting trips on it. The drive manual specifies the protection; a slow-curve device or a breaker of the recommended type stops it. A drive whose inrush has grown, because a precharge resistor or a relay has failed, is the exception.
- The clamp meter says the load is well under the rating.
- Check three things: whether the meter reads true current, since harmonics make an average-reading meter read low; the panel temperature, since the breaker derates; and the terminals, since a loose one heats the breaker from outside. Then consider a weakened breaker.
- How many times can a breaker trip before it should be replaced?
- Manufacturers rate breakers for a number of fault interruptions and a larger number of overload trips; a small breaker that has tripped dozens of times, or interrupted a real short, is suspect. A breaker that trips at less than its rating on a bench test is replaced.
- Can I put two loads on one breaker to stop the trips on the other one?
- Only within the rating and the conductor ampacity, and not if one is a motor or a transformer whose inrush will trip the shared breaker. Each load type wants its own protection matched to it; sharing is how the circuit got overloaded in the first place.
Related topics
- Circuit Breakers in Control PanelsMiniature, molded-case, and supplementary protectors: what each is listed to do, how a trip curve is read, where the NEC and UL 508A set the rules, and how breaker choice drives the short-circuit current rating of the whole panel.
- Fuses in Control PanelsFuse classes, time-delay and fast-acting types, current limitation and what it does for the panel short-circuit rating, semiconductor fuses for drives, control circuit and DC fusing, and the habits that make a blown fuse a diagnosis instead of a mystery.
- Panel OverheatingA panel that runs hot: drives tripping on temperature in the afternoon, controllers faulting in summer, components discolored, a fan that never stops. The causes from an undersized enclosure to a clogged filter, measuring the rise, and the fixes.
- Fuse Blows RepeatedlyA control fuse that opens again after replacement has a cause the replacement did not touch: a shorted coil, a ground fault in a wet field device, an overloaded circuit, the wrong fuse type for inrush, or an intermittent short. How the timing identifies it.
- UL 508A Industrial Control PanelsWhat the listing actually covers, what has to appear on the label, and the requirements that most often cause a panel to fail inspection.
- High Neutral-to-Ground VoltageWhat a neutral-to-ground voltage reading means, the values that are normal, and the causes of a high one: a long or heavily loaded neutral, harmonic current, a loose or open neutral, a missing service bond, or an extra bond downstream, and telling them apart.
Direct contact
Have a controls question?
Reach Eric Sullivan directly about anything on this site, a controls or automation topic, or one of his personal projects.